Differential Pricing

What is Differential Pricing?

Differential pricing is a pricing strategy where businesses set different prices for the same product or service based on multiple factors. Common factors include the customer’s location, time of purchase, purchase history, price sensitivity, and ability to pay.

There are a few ways businesses usually implement differential pricing:

• Price localization — Changing prices when operating in different regions nationally or internationally to account for purchasing power and local competition.
• Price discrimination — Charging customers different prices based on how much they are willing to pay, their purchasing habits, or other factors.
• Price differentiation – Setting different prices for the same product or service based on various factors such as customer demographics, location, or purchasing behavior.
• Volume discounts — Offering discounts when customers purchase multiple products or services at once.
• Subscription-based pricing — Offering discounts to customers who sign up for long-term purchases or subscriptions.
• Price matching — Reducing prices to equal or beat a competitor’s in an effort to win new business or retain a customer.
• Seasonal discounts — Discounting items during specific times each year, such as a holiday or end-of-the-year sale.
• Real-time pricing — Continuously moving prices up or down based on current demand, availability, and competition.

The differential facilitates a free market system where prices are based on supply and demand. It emphasizes a dynamic pricing model, which results in continuous price optimization. When implemented appropriately, differential pricing allows businesses to maximize revenue by offering fair market rates for each customer individually.

Synonyms

• Price differentiation
• Discriminatory pricing
• Dual pricing
• Flexible pricing
• Multiple pricing
• Variable pricing

Why Companies Use Differential Pricing Strategies

A product rarely costs the same across the board. The costs of doing business are different everywhere, and people generally expect most products to cost more or less at certain times of the year or at different locations.

There are several reasons a company might use a differential pricing strategy:

• Incentivize larger purchases. SaaS companies offer one or two months free for purchasing a year-long subscription upfront because it guarantees customer retention for at least a year. Retailers and ecommerce sellers would rather turn over their inventory faster, so they offer lower per-unit prices to buyers who purchase multiple items.
• Compete at local rates. Local consumers are less willing to purchase a product when its price doesn’t accurately reflect their local costs. The Big Mac Index is a great example of how different countries have different price points for the same product.
• Capitalize on periods of increased demand. Companies use dynamic pricing to increase prices for items that are in high demand. This is common practice for airlines and hotels, which tend to charge more during peak travel times or popular events. It’s also effective when launching a new, ‘innovative’ product — when Apple releases a new iPhone, for example.
• Establish a foothold in a new market. Sometimes, differential pricing is an aggressive strategy for entering a new market. Companies use penetration pricing to gain customers, then gradually increase prices once they have brand awareness and a certain level of customer approval.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Differential Pricing

Differential pricing is sometimes referred to as “discriminatory.” Although that term has a negative connotation, differential pricing can be beneficial for both consumers and businesses when it’s used in the right context.

However, it can be a double-edged sword. Its advantages are only realized if it’s used in a fair and balanced way. Companies should always avoid using a differential pricing strategy that might appear discriminatory on the basis of race, ethnicity, gender, or any other protected class.

Benefits of Differential Pricing

Expands Market

Price (or, more accurately, price management) is one of the four Ps. For most kinds of businesses, differential pricing is integral to sales and marketing. And it’s a crucial element of market expansion.

Let’s say Company A sells soft drinks in U.S. markets, but they noticed an uptick in Google and social media searches for the product in Mexico. They know locals are interested in their products, and they’ve considered expanding for some time. But, in Mexico, the local market is less likely to pay what Americans do for the same soft drinks.

Company A has to change its prices to meet the demands of the Mexican market. Since the cost of doing business (real estate/rent, salaries, etc.) is lower in Mexico than it is in the U.S., Company A can lower its prices and still make a profit.

The same concept would work for a SaaS company trying to target a new type of customer. Suppose they’ve refined their product to meet the needs of a specific audience, like small business owners or freelancers. They could advertise that prospects who fit those categories qualify for a discount or a free trial period. Eventually, they’ll convert more new customers this way.

Increases Revenues

A dynamic pricing strategy is what allows businesses operate with the highest degree of profitability.

It allows businesses to take advantages of surge pricing, which can bring in large profits during peak sales periods. It also allows businesses to manage the balance between supply and demand more effectively, ensuring they’re not stuck with excess inventory or low cash flow when demand is low.

In the off-season, reducing prices, listing items on sale, or offering special discounts to certain types of customers can bring new customers in who would have otherwise never considered buying.

Improves Sales Ratio

Because price differentiation plays into current market dynamics, the sales ratio — cost of sales divided by revenue — improves when companies use it.

Customer acquisition costs are lower because the sales team doesn’t have to spend as much time convincing buyers. Plus, customers who purchase a product during a discounted period will likely return and make additional purchases.

Especially when price variations help them sell into one market more completely, they can move a considerably higher sales volume at greater efficiency in the same amount of time.

Optimizes Production Processes

For retailers, wholesalers, and ecommerce brands, differential pricing directly correlates to streamlined production. When products sit on shelves for too long, inventory costs eat into profits. It’s (almost) always better to sell out.

Since price differentiation is closely tied to supply and demand, companies can anticipate these fluctuations in their production strategy. They know when to increase production and when to scale back, eliminating some of the pressure of over/understocking.

Drawbacks of Differential Pricing

Price Sensitivity

Some groups are more sensitive to price changes than others. And some products are more elastic. If the current market price and price elasticity are misaligned, buyers won’t react positively to changes in pricing plans.

In every case, however, what customers really want is consistency. The more prices change (for better or for worse), the less likely a change is to be well-received by customers.

This is particularly true for goods that require semi-frequent repeat purchases, such as food, shampoo, or toothpaste. To some extent, they would buy these products anyway. But they look for consistency and reliability from vendors more than anything.

Subscription services (e.g., streaming, SaaS) face the same problem when they attempt to change their prices too often. Subscribers expect to pay the same monthly price, so any substantial change can turn them away from the service.

Perception of Bias

Differential pricing can be perceived as unfair, creating an “us vs. them” mentality among customers, especially if it’s not done in a way that benefits all customers. This can lead to customer dissatisfaction and possibly loss of trust in the brand.

Reducing prices for a market segment on the basis of income or socioeconomic background also tends to make the higher-value customers value the product less. Although making a product more affordable for everyone sounds good in theory, businesses that do this often alienate their most valuable customers.

A willingness to charge less whenever a company gets the opportunity could lead to a situation where nobody wants to pay the full price. In the worst cases, this could cause a brand or product to seem “cheap,” making longtime customers lose interest.

Legal Implications

Even if they aren’t, a business that appears to be conducting differential pricing based on illegal or unethical grounds can face public outrage and legal action. Companies should be especially careful when operating in international markets, where different laws may apply.

The best way to avoid this kind of problem is to make sure pricing plans don’t discriminate against any specific group or class of people. There are also certain deceptive and illegal pricing tactics businesses should avoid, such as price fixing and predatory pricing.

Can Lead to Price Wars

Differential pricing can lead to competition with companies that offer the same product/service at lower prices. This can result in a price war, which negatively impacts the company’s bottom line.

In situations like this, companies should focus on other aspects of their product/service that can help differentiate them from the competition. This could include better customer service, higher quality goods or services, more features, or even a unique approach to pricing (e.g., tiered plans).

Types of Differential Pricing

Customer Segment-Based

Segment-based differential pricing typically happens when companies want to target a specific type of buyer. They’ll offer some sort of promotion for customers that meet certain criteria to get more of them in the door. This usually includes demographic information (age, gender, income level) or firmographic information (company size, revenue).

This pricing strategy works well as part of a short-term campaign to quickly expand market share. It’s usually met with messaging like, “If you’re a man aged 18-35 who doesn’t have a lot of disposable income, this product is for you.”

Companies may also offer a first-time buyer discount or a loyalty reward. This is a great way to incentivize customers who continue to make purchases from the company, which can help increase customer retention.

Time-Based

Time-based pricing typically works in one of four ways:

• Seasonally — Companies will adjust prices based on the time of year. This could include discounts during holidays or sales events.
• Periodically — Companies can also offer short-term deals or scheduled discounts to create urgency and encourage people to purchase quickly.
• Event Driven — In this scenario, companies offer promotions in response to specific events like natural disasters, in-demand local events (e.g., a music festival), or large economic changes.
• Proximity — Airline tickets typically cost less when customers book them months in advance.

Sometimes, time-based differentials will be combined with customer segment-based differentials. For example, a company may offer discounts to students during peak travel times.

Location-Based

Location-based pricing is typically used by retail businesses that have multiple physical stores in different locations. Since the cost of living (and, therefore, the price of goods and services) varies from place to place, companies may adjust their prices based on the region they’re in. This is especially the case when companies produce their products locally.

Demand might also play a role in pricing. In rural or far-off areas, delivering products costs a lot more than in densely populated areas. In Hawaii, for instance, many items cost more than they do on the mainland due to shipping costs.

Volume-Based

Manufacturers and wholesalers often offer price breaks to customers who purchase in bulk. Volume-based pricing can be used for both short-term campaigns (e.g., “Buy 3, get 1 free”) or long-term customer loyalty programs (e.g., loyalty points).

This pricing strategy works well for businesses with long-term customers who make frequent purchases. It incentivizes them to buy more to get the best deal, while ensuring they remain loyal customers longer.

Brand Image-Based

For whatever reason, some brands are simply viewed as luxury items in certain markets. So, customers are willing to pay more for them. Companies that use brand image-based pricing will often employ high-end marketing tactics, such as celebrity endorsements or high profile events, to create the perception of exclusivity.

This pricing strategy is effective because it allows companies to charge a premium without increasing their costs. It also helps increase customer loyalty and the perceived value of the product or service.

Competition-Based

It’s common for retailers to price-match to stay competitive in their market. This type of differential pricing often works in the favor of customers, as they’re able to get the best price while shopping around.

Many companies also change their prices based on competitor activity. When the general market trends up or down, they will typically follow the herd.

Differential Pricing Examples

Example 1: SaaS Company – Adobe Creative Cloud

Adobe Creative Cloud, a suite of creative tools, offers variable pricing for certain customer segments. The Photoshop and Illustrator vendor offers over 60% off to students and teachers. This allows people who might not otherwise be able to afford their service to have access at a reduced rate.

Example 2: Retailer – Walmart

The world’s largest retail giant uses competition-based differential pricing. They have a price-match policy —they match the price of any identical item sold online or by physical retailers like Target. That way, they win customers’ business instead of turning them to a cheaper direct competitor.

Example 3: Airline – Delta Airlines

Delta Airlines utilizes time-based differential pricing. Tickets prices fluctuate based on the time of purchase, demand, and seasonality. For instance, booking a flight months in advance is usually cheaper than booking a few days before the flight. Similarly, prices may rise during peak travel times like holidays and drop during low-demand periods.

Technology Requirements for Executing a Differential Pricing Strategy

Differential pricing is a data- and software-driven process. Since pricing analytics are virtually impossible without the help of algorithms and automation, companies need to invest in the right tech stack for it to work.

Here’s a list of software platforms businesses use to execute differential pricing:

• Data analytics and visualization tools, including data warehouses, SQL databases, spreadsheets, and customer data platforms (CDPs)
• Business intelligence platforms with customer segmentation capabilities
• Configure, price, quote (CPQ) software
• Pricing automation and optimization software, such as a pricing engine
• CRM software with customer segmentation capabilities
• Ecommerce and point-of-sale (POS) systems
• Payment processors and secure payment gateways
• Billing and subscription management software
• Competitor analysis tools
• Social listening software
• Compliance management system (many billing and subscription platforms have this built-in)
• Marketing automation (to communicate pricing changes and offers)
• An integration platform like Zapier to connect different software applications

Best Practices for Implementing Price Differentiation

Implementing a successful price differentiation strategy involves several best practices to ensure consumer expectations align with product pricing.

1. Segmentation Analysis

Conduct a thorough analysis of your customer base to identify distinct segments based on demographics, purchasing behavior, or other relevant factors. Understand the unique needs and preferences of each segment.

2. Use Value-Based Pricing

Align your pricing with the perceived value of your product or service for each customer segment. Consider the specific benefits and features that are most valued by each group and set prices accordingly.

3. Implement Dynamic Pricing

Dynamic pricing models allow real-time adjustments based on market conditions, demand fluctuations, or changes in customer behavior. This flexibility enables you to capture maximum value.

4. Transparent Communication

Clearly communicate the rationale behind different prices to avoid customer confusion or resentment. Transparency builds trust and helps customers understand the value they receive at their respective price points.

5. Leverage Data Analytics

Leverage data analytics to continually monitor customer behavior, market trends, and competitive pricing. Regularly update your pricing strategy based on insights gained from data analysis.

6. Customization and Bundling

Offer customizable options or bundled product packages that cater to different customer preferences. This allows customers to choose the features that matter most to them, adding perceived value to the overall offering.

7. Monitor Legal Compliance

Ensure that your price differentiation practices comply with relevant laws and regulations to avoid legal issues. Discrimination should be based on legitimate factors, and businesses should be transparent about their pricing practices.

8. Test and Iterate

Test different pricing strategies through controlled experiments or pilot programs before implementing them broadly. Continuously gather feedback and iterate on your approach based on the results.

9. Gather Customer Feedback 

Monitor customer feedback and satisfaction levels related to pricing changes. Address concerns promptly and adjust your strategy if needed to maintain positive customer relationships.

10. Conduct Competitor Analysis

Stay informed about your competitors’ pricing strategies and market positioning. This knowledge can help you identify opportunities for differentiation and ensure your prices remain competitive within the industry.

By combining these best practices, businesses can implement a more effective and nuanced price differentiation strategy that maximizes revenue while meeting the diverse needs of their customer base.

People Also Ask